I love e.l.f. This liner had been the easiest one in liquid form for me to use. It goes on so smooth and lasts the whole night through.

Elf did it again! I love all my elf products but this eyeliner is everything! From the wand being easy to handle and the cute typical packaging. My favorite part is the lack of scent. It glideded on so smooth and was easy to control when I was touching up. For this price I'm stocking up and handing them out as gifts!

Affordable This a great eyeliner for cheap! It's easy to use and doesn't smudge.

Amazing value I used this for years! Easy to apply and super cheap!

freesamplewithout spending shipping cost freesample whit out spending shiping cost of black aye liner

My 'go-to' for any look!! I give this elf liner 5 stars because it's very bold and last all day. The way it glides on so easy is almost calming. No running when applied or cracking once it's dried. It had a really thin brush tip to get precise lines and details. The price of this elf liquid liner is a great price of $2 at my Walmart, You can't beat that. I live it and I'm sure everyone else does too.

Great lines! This is just another Elf product that I love! I like the wand and it was easy to apply. It is a more liquid formula, but I didn't have too much trouble getting it to stay where I wanted it. It dries pretty fast too. It's super affordable and works great for me! I definitely recommend trying this eyeliner! Elf products are amazing!!!

I had never used a liquid eye liner before purchasing this product. I had purchased other e.l.f products before and really liked them. I like the coverage of this product, but I don't like ow I have to keep my eyes closed for about a minute after applying to make sure the liner is dry. The color seems to stay on really well and I have enjoyed using it for more dramatic night looks.

I LOVE THIS EYELINER!! This is the best, BUT at times its consistency isn't as good as it should be. I do think it works well for it's price. ELF PRODUCTS ARE THE BEST!!

I really like this liner. The only thing i'd say that i was disappointed about was how long you have to wait for it to dry.

I really like this eyeliner!! The only thing about it that is keeping me from giving it a fifth star is the fact that the first time I used it the applicator broke. I didn't get too upset, it was only a dollar after all!! It's still very usuable, and I use it every day. It stays on better than a traditional 'crayon' type eyeliner (which I use on the bottom of my eyes). It keeps a dark line with out ever smudging or flaking which is super important to me. I'm pretty picky about which products I use on my eyes and this one passes my 'snob' test, hands down!!

i actually really like this product. It glides on easy and stays on all day!

I have struggled to fine an eyeliner that will give me the smooth line for the look I wanted to enhance my eyes, this product works great for me and is easy to use, the price is really a great deal.

I wish they offered more color choices. I would like to see forest green, plum, copper to name a few. I also agree the applicator needs to be tweaked some to leave a thinner line. I was glad to see that Target had a gift 3 pack with black, silver and gold in it- fun!

I have this as well and totally agree that it takes much practice. I'm not so fantastic at it yet. Thus, if i spread it too thinly, it will crack. But if I do 2 coats, it works much better!