I forgot my eyeliner when I was on vacation and my sister m-in-law borrowed me her liquid elf eyeliner. I was not a fan, it chipped away throughout the day and just made me look like a mess in a couple hours. I would suggest going for a benefits push-up liner instead. It's a gel with the procession of liquid and it last all day versus about an hour or two.

I forgot my eyeliner when I was on vacation and my sister m-in-law borrowed me her liquid elf eyeliner. I was not a fan, it chipped away throughout the day and just made me look like a mess in a couple hours. I would suggest going for a benefits push-up liner instead. It's a gel with the procession of liquid and it last all day versus about an hour or two.

Initially, I like it and I still use it. However, after reading all the other reviews, I believe it was just ignoring the major issues with this product. Wisk i could have loved it because I am in the market for a new eyeliner brand!

Initially, I like it and I still use it. However, after reading all the other reviews, I believe it was just ignoring the major issues with this product. Wisk i could have loved it because I am in the market for a new eyeliner brand!

Affordable and dark color but don't care the brush. Prefer a hard liner to draw with.

Affordable and dark color but don't care the brush. Prefer a hard liner to draw with.

Comes on nice and smooth but then smudges and smeares. Also, not water proof.

Comes on nice and smooth but then smudges and smeares. Also, not water proof.

Didn't like it,dries and peels. Can't define lines

Didn't like it,dries and peels. Can't define lines

This is an awesome product the only thing that is unfortunate about it is that It doesn't stay on my oily skin all day. Midway throughout my day I have to retrace my wing that was placed earlier.

This is an awesome product the only thing that is unfortunate about it is that It doesn't stay on my oily skin all day. Midway throughout my day I have to retrace my wing that was placed earlier.

I kind had problems with this but would like to try something simlier

I kind had problems with this but would like to try something simlier

Love this brand of eyeliner! The tip is very fine and easy to draw a straight and even line. I use the blackest black color. Very inexpensive! Definetly worth trying for anyone that uses liquid eyeliner.

Love this brand of eyeliner! The tip is very fine and easy to draw a straight and even line. I use the blackest black color. Very inexpensive! Definetly worth trying for anyone that uses liquid eyeliner.

Smooth and cheap...love this product. Long lasting too

Smooth and cheap...love this product. Long lasting too

I absolutely love this eyeliner. It is very inexpensive and great quality. I also like that it is easy to use and available almost everywhere.

I absolutely love this eyeliner. It is very inexpensive and great quality. I also like that it is easy to use and available almost everywhere.

Good for how much it is. It stays on for a good amount of time and is easy to use. I feel as if the product dries up quickly but I do get a lot of use out of ot. It is not that best liquid eyeliner I have useful, but it does the job.

Good for how much it is. It stays on for a good amount of time and is easy to use. I feel as if the product dries up quickly but I do get a lot of use out of ot. It is not that best liquid eyeliner I have useful, but it does the job.

I'm not really sure how long the actual liner stays on or anything. All I know is that the brush-type applicator was totally useless. I tried using this product once and it was so hard to achieve just a single precise line, I gave up. This isn't good, even for the low price.

I'm not really sure how long the actual liner stays on or anything. All I know is that the brush-type applicator was totally useless. I tried using this product once and it was so hard to achieve just a single precise line, I gave up. This isn't good, even for the low price.

Love this eyeliner! Perfect for a sleek cat eye look!!

Love this eyeliner! Perfect for a sleek cat eye look!!

I bought this to practice doing winged liner because I didn't want to shell out a lot of money just to waste it but this stuff really surprised me. It lasted all day, as long as it wasn't hot out (this isn't waterproof) and I didn't experience any flaking. The only downside is that is does take a little while to dry but as I don't have a lot of experience with liquid line, i'm not if that's par for the course or not. Even if you didn't want to use this everyday, this makes a great practice liner if you suck at doing wings like me :)

I bought this to practice doing winged liner because I didn't want to shell out a lot of money just to waste it but this stuff really surprised me. It lasted all day, as long as it wasn't hot out (this isn't waterproof) and I didn't experience any flaking. The only downside is that is does take a little while to dry but as I don't have a lot of experience with liquid line, i'm not if that's par for the course or not. Even if you didn't want to use this everyday, this makes a great practice liner if you suck at doing wings like me :)

Good product for the price, but takes forever to dry and smudges VERY easily.

Good product for the price, but takes forever to dry and smudges VERY easily.