Too "thin" as in too watery. I think that because of the consistency, it does not maintain my lashes shape all day.

I felt this mascara does not last throughout the day. Was very disappointed with this product.

pointless does absolutely nothing @!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This brand irritates my eyes, but I did end up using it a couple times before purchasing a new mascara. When I used it my lashes looked like spider legs and didn't make my lashes any thicker. The one thing I did like was the application brush, I was able to catch my smaller lashes easily. It may work for some people, but this product unfortunately didn't work for me!

Does the trick but tested on animals

This is an ok mascara. It separates my lashes nicely but doesn't give them much body or volume. I love the brush though and how easy it is to use.

This mascara is a classic! Will always use. Great product!

I like this mascara. I really do. For the drugstore price, it is pretty good. However, I think there are a few out there that are drugstore price and better quality. I don't feel as if I get as thick and lengthy lashes with this mascara as I do others.

I did not like this product. It makes my lashes feel hard and flaky.

This is a product that you will always be able to use. It does a good job and the waterproof stays put with no runs. I do feel there are better drugstore mascaras made. I wouldn't choose this one over the "falsies", but it is ok if it's all you have in your bag.

Although the product works wel I can't wear Maybelline anymore due to allergies.

I feel nostolgic buying this mascara but after wearing I always question myself..why? It doesn't last, flakes, and clumps. I need tokeep this in mind next time.

This mascara is so Iconic. I remember my mom using it. I used it when I was a teenager. Now I like a little more dramatic lash. I want volume and length. This mascara isn't the best for that kind of look. If you want a basic everyday natural looking lash this is the mascara for you. It is a good mascara though. Doesn't flake and seperates nicely with no clumping.

 I really liked the lightweight feel of this product. The texture is very silky and smooth. The color was a perfect for my skin tone. It provided great coverage. Overall, this is a very good, light and sheer foundation.

This mascara is good it is very inexpensive and it works great on my eyelashes.