I liked this liquid eyeliner alot, my absolute favorite liquid liner will always be l'oreal liner intense felt tip pen in carbon black but this definitely comes in second(Avon used to make a liner just like this e.l.f. liner but sadly they stopped making it, but since i've found this one i'm okay again! ) !! I absolutely love the brush, i do not like the flimsy liquid liner brushes some brands have i find for me they dont work as well to get a very precise even line , I like the more stiff brush like this one has. My only problem with this eyeliner is it does take awhile to dry and sometimes when it drys the finish in some places does not apear to be the same and so i have to reapply in those areas to get it to be as dark and shiney as other areas are, but other than that i really like this product and will repurchase over and over! I love e.l.f. products, for the price and quality , I have rarely beed disappointed by anything from their line and will continue to buy products from them as well as try out some products t)hat i have not yet used because i know that i will not be dissapointed!

I bought this because it was dirt cheap and I wanted to try to re-create that winged eyeliner look. It went on fairly smooth and looked good for a little while, but it didn't have much staying power on my oily skin, and ultimately slid off.

I love elf , but this eyeliner is not really good, dont last much time!!

i have never used eyeliner before so I thought I would give this one a try. I have to say I was somewhat happy with the look I got using this product. I think I just have to keep using it to get used to the way it looks on me. I have always just used eyeliner on my lower eyelids, but will be making adjustments from here on out.

Acturally I prefer the brown color.

inam a fan of E.L.F cosmetics, but this yeliner is a bit watered down.

e.l.f. Cosmetics Liquid Eyeliner is a good product. e.l.f has amazing prices and this was a bargain. I would purchase this again

I'd give it a 3.5 if I could. I like the value being only $1 I can easily buy a bunch at a time. The problems is it can be a little runny, but not too much to turn me off. Overall it is a great eyeliner even with it's little quirks.

This is actually a pretty good liquid eyeliner for only $1!! It's one of my favorites

I don't wear eyeliner all the time and I also prefer a pencil liner as opposed to liquid, but, elf's liquid eyeliner is decent. It's very affordable and is easy to apply.

This product is very easy to apply, however it is not very pigmented. I have this in black, and it goes on very well but looks almost watery at times. I have to keep applying it to get a pure black color. This product works very well for using over a pencil liner to lock it in more!

I bought this liner in brown. It is nice and dark and easy for me to apply. The only problem I have with it is that it does tend to flake just a little during the day. For the price I think it is a good liquid liner to try.

Okay but there only $1 which is great. You get what you pay for. Clumpy and smelled a little weird. I would reccomend it to a friend though because i find myself running to it when im in desperate need.

I give this product a 3 star rating. Maybe it was just the one i got maybe not but it wasnt very pigmented either. It also seemed to dry out a little. But..it is cheap and after working with it its good for the price. i always keep a few laying around just in case.

Messy.