Super good product :D this was my first ever liquid eyeliner that i have tried and it worked amazing for my first time !

I love this! It didn't run, even when I got heated. The color lasts very long and it is a VERY good price for such a good product.

Goes on smooth and doesn't dry out.

I tried Elf's black liquid eyeliner this month for the first time (it came in my Elf beauty bundle) and I love it! The applicator is easy to use and it goes on smoothly. I did not have a problem with it smudging or fading. My eyes water a lot but this product did not cause burning or bother me in any way. I highly recommend trying it!

Works just as good as most other liquid liners. Great price. Although I wish the brush were a little thinner to get a more precise line.

I got this to try something new but I'm just not a fan of liquid eyeliner at all.

Yep!

Great product exceptional quality for the price! Lasts for hours water proof and affordable! Highly recommended

Stays on all day. The applicator is very stiff, the liquid is very black. it is just an exceptional product for the one dollar spent.

This eyeliner is amazing!!! My line comes out really clean and it doesn't smudge.

great product, really worth the dollar you pay for it, and it last for a long while.

I purchased this E.l.f liquid eyeliner, and it was the first time I ever attempted to use liquid eyeliner so it is hard for me to compare to other products. However, it was easier then I expected and I liked that it came off very easily. I usually use cream eyeliner or pencil and usually have a hard time getting it off before going to bed. But this made my make-up removal process so much easier and faster I know that I will continue to use this product.

I really love this eyeliner! It dries fast and last all day! I love that this does not smudge, and with the fine tip it makes really defined lines and is easy to use.

Great product really worth the dollar you pay for it and it last for long while.

This is my go-to, cheap liquid liner. I have repurchased probably 5 times. It does take a little longer to dry,but if you wave your hand I think it dries pretty quickly. And matte! Will continue to repurchase in between my high end liners.