I purchased this E.l.f liquid eyeliner, and it was the first time I ever attempted to use liquid eyeliner so it is hard for me to compare to other products. However, it was easier then I expected and I liked that it came off very easily. I usually use cream eyeliner or pencil and usually have a hard time getting it off before going to bed. But this made my make-up removal process so much easier and faster I know that I will continue to use this product.

I really love this eyeliner! It dries fast and last all day! I love that this does not smudge, and with the fine tip it makes really defined lines and is easy to use.

Great product really worth the dollar you pay for it and it last for long while.

This is my go-to, cheap liquid liner. I have repurchased probably 5 times. It does take a little longer to dry,but if you wave your hand I think it dries pretty quickly. And matte! Will continue to repurchase in between my high end liners.

I have a lot of elf makeup and I adore the brand. The eyeliner doesn't clump up and dry out as fast as other brands I have tried before. I would recommend all elf products to anyone! My friends love the way I do my eyes and I always use elf eyeliner and eye shadow!

A holy grail product for me! And you just can't beat the price!

I have to say that I definitely love this eyeliner , i believe it is only 1$ and it works soo good and it lasts around 5- 7 hours :)

the only liquid eyeliner I'll use. it glides on well and it's a great price.

This is my go-to eyeliner! I love it and have bought it several times. Its quality outweighs its cost and I will continue using it!

Love this eyeliner! It has a long lasting wear for a super adorable price! It's very pigmented as well which is a must in my eyeliner must haves!

I got some for christmas and it works. It always gave me a perfect line, very easy to use

I love this product, not only for the price but also for the quality! I use this everyday as well as the precision liner to create the perfect winged liner! I choose this over the million other eyeliner products I own. Will keep repurchasing as well!

I don't usually gave 5 stars but I loveeee elf liquid black liner ! They don't smear (at least on me they don't) long lasting till you wash it off. I always by like 3 at a time and they stay very black. The tip is also sharp. So cheap too 1$ thank you elf for making these.

Love this brand of eyeliner! The tip is very fine and easy to draw a straight and even line. I use the blackest black color. Very inexpensive! Definetly worth trying for anyone that uses liquid eyeliner.

I have this and I love how it look with my eyes it goes on smooth and it last all day