I can't use it really on my eye. Every time I try to apply it it doesn't even get close to my lash line and looks gross on me haha

I honestly have not been favoring elf products.

not great quality, was a little flaky. I prefer maybelline stilleto for a bargain

My mom uses this everyday and it last all day.

I really was disappointed in this eyeliner. I love ELF products but this was just terrible on me. It did not last very long and it flaked off very easily

product is fair...good for the price, but these's better on the market.

not so great, smudges easily

The brush is very flimsy and it fades and smudges a lot. It's not dark enough you have to put layers on just to get a dark cat eye look.

It was extremely watered down upon opening it. When I went to apply it, EVERYWHERE. In my eye, my eye lashes, you name it. I didn't enjoy the product.

As they say you get what you pay for...and at a dollar this is just that a dollar eye liner..it is watery does not stay on long and gives me raccoon eyes after awhile...but on the flip side it is a dollar!!

I have always had issues with liquid eyeliners because they always make my eyes itch! I might be allergic or something, but this eyeliner did just that-it made my eyes itch. I love the E.L.F. brand, but this product just did not make the cut.

In this case.. You get what you pay for. My teenage daughter LOVES it but me , not so much. Came off very easily. I like my eyeliners to stay put until I take them off.

Did not like this product. It was cheap but I guess you get what you pay for. It was hard to apply and messy.

I've tried this and thrown it in my purse for occasional use when i'm desperate, this is one of those that I find starts out fine but fades through the day, blah.

Nice tip that was easy to apply, great dark black color, but it did smear.