I absolutely hated this mascara! It guess it does make your eyelashes look longer, but also clumpy! I could live with the way it looks, but the worst part is taking it off. It does not come off!! You can use makeup remover and wash your face, look up and have all the black "beauty tubes" all over your face! or they are half hanging off your eyelashes. so annoying!! im all for a mascara that lasts though the day, but I need it to wash off as well...and not leave little black things all over me!

Smudge proof, great length, BUT as the previous reviewer stated, this tube of mascara doesn't warrant a natural look. I would definitely not wear this for daywear. It kind of looks like plastic. Also, even after using my Shu Uemura eyelash curler, I got no kind of volume out of this mascara. I would only wear this mascara at night, like when an occasion calls for dramatic eyes because this makes your eyelashes look kind of drag-like. Removal is nice, as you don't need eye makeup remover. Just use warm water and pull the tubes off (they look like squiggly lines).

It's been working ok for me it's not really what I would call amazing

I use to use this mascara all the time. It gave me lots of length. I really did love this mascara, I reached for it almost everytime I put makeup on. Best part about it is, it was so easy to remove from my eyelashes.

Great length -- doesn't smudge & give me the look of an afternoon raccoon

The best feature of this mascara is that it will not smudge. The drawback is the 2 step application. I didn't like the white primer because I wasn't able to complete coat and cover it with the mascara. I could still see white parts on my lashes.

LOVE this mascara! i ended up falling asleep with it on and the next day still looked great on.

I was a bit skeptical when I saw the ads, but figured it was worth a try, as I had a 1/2 off coupon. This stuff is GREAT for making my lashes look thick and long, and it does last all day. But- when it comes to removing it- "soap and water" is NOT going to do it, unless you really scrub, which of course is not something we want to do, especially around the eyes. I use a make-up remover cloth- ya' know, the "baby wipe" looking kind?- and the mascara comes off just fine.

I do not use mascara but daughter does and wants this product every time

Great mascara, not quite as good as I would have liked but for the amount you pay it doesn't get any better!

worked great

Makes me look like I have long lashes again.

good

I think it's one of the very best drug store mascaras. It makes my skinny, short, invisible lashes long, lush, and gorgeous. Does indeed stay on all day. Just washing my face at night removes it. Oh, it doesn't make my allergic eyes itch either. For me that's a biggie.

I have problems with it clumping and leaving me with 'spikey' eyelashes. But it does lengthen and has tremendous staying power.