I'm a sometimes fan of elf cosmetics. Being a makeup artist, I'm a bit picky with my products. This product was OK. It is definitely not something I will add to my kit due to it being so runny and smudging so much. But really, it is only $1 and you get what you pay for here.

Not a big fan of liquid liner.

Elf is usually my go to because its cheep and most things work well but this one was runny even after i put powder under it for it to stick to and then once it did dry it would just flake off, I definitely won't be repurchasing this product

One of my least favorite elf products. Smells strange, and goes on very streaky.

It was ok. A bit runny and I had to reapply.

Not the island our product that I would choose to use?

I didn't like this eyeliner. And I'm a big eyeliner girl. This takes forever to dry and just doesn't last.

Im not a huge fan of any e.l.f products, but I especially dislike the liquid liner, its messy and it smudges.

The gel is better but it's convenient tho.. Its cheap and I'm starting to really love elf cosmetics

I love E.L.F. Products so I bought this liquid eyeliner and was very disappointed. It peels off quickly after applying.

Personally my Teen and i love the elf brand but this eyeliner is a miss for us both yes it glides on perfectly smooth but after about 2 hours of wear it never seems to fail to start flaking off on us both , we tried and tried again to give it another chance but to no avail , this product is not for us .

I really like elf products because they are great quality and also are inexpensive as well. However I wasnt a fan of this liquid eyeliner. It doesn't stay on well without smudging on parts of the waterline and also smears easily and doesn't stay put. I was kind of disappointed :(

Comes on nice and smooth but then smudges and smeares. Also, not water proof.

Initially, I like it and I still use it. However, after reading all the other reviews, I believe it was just ignoring the major issues with this product. Wisk i could have loved it because I am in the market for a new eyeliner brand!

I forgot my eyeliner when I was on vacation and my sister m-in-law borrowed me her liquid elf eyeliner. I was not a fan, it chipped away throughout the day and just made me look like a mess in a couple hours. I would suggest going for a benefits push-up liner instead. It's a gel with the procession of liquid and it last all day versus about an hour or two.