I dislike the final look of this eyeliner. It is very plastic like and super unnatural looking. It is not too hard to apply if you're used to the thin brushes. I usually wear gel liner or pencil eyeliner so I am used to making thicker lines. May work for you if you like super thin lines. I personally will not buy again. I use the brush for nail art now :P

I have bought a lot of elf products and have loved most of them, sadly not this one. The eyeliner is very hard to apply compared to most liquid eyeliners and it smells bad too! Once you finally get it applyed to your eye, it usually flakes off too quickly to even bother. I would say, save your money and get a little higher quality eye liner!

im not to crazy about this product. tthe brush of it makes it a bit difficult to apply it feels and looks like a cheap brush but for $3 how can you really go wrong

the applicator came to me bent and out of shape the color is very black but smudges.

I did not like this product and I'm actually a fan of elf cosmetics. I found the bottle and applicator awkward, the solution was too thin, and it did not last. I had to apply this and then go over the line several times because the solution was so thin. It never looked right. It dried funny and it rubbed off way too easily. I know this is not an expensive designer product but I've used other products from elf and have been quite satisfied.

Very Messy & it takes to long to dry on your eye.

this eyeliner is very inexpensive but the quality is not that good i have to go over the line about three times so it can look as dark as i want it to look. Its good to buy if you dont have any and want to use it once

I can't use it really on my eye. Every time I try to apply it it doesn't even get close to my lash line and looks gross on me haha

I honestly have not been favoring elf products.

not great quality, was a little flaky. I prefer maybelline stilleto for a bargain

My mom uses this everyday and it last all day.

I really was disappointed in this eyeliner. I love ELF products but this was just terrible on me. It did not last very long and it flaked off very easily

product is fair...good for the price, but these's better on the market.

not so great, smudges easily

The brush is very flimsy and it fades and smudges a lot. It's not dark enough you have to put layers on just to get a dark cat eye look.