I really like this eye liner a lot. It is so affordable and easy to use. My only complaint is that there isn't many color choices. One color that I really want to see if plum. Other than that, I LOVE it and it doesnt break my beauty fund.

I bought this because it was dirt cheap and I wanted to try to re-create that winged eyeliner look. It went on fairly smooth and looked good for a little while, but it didn't have much staying power on my oily skin, and ultimately slid off.

I use this eyeliner all the time. It is great for the price, its only a $1. Not bad at all!!!

This stuff is pretty good. I just don't like the applicator part of it (the sponge) is a bit too thick but its a very nice eyeliner.

i have this product, have been using it for a couple months, I love it

I have this as well and totally agree that it takes much practice. I'm not so fantastic at it yet. Thus, if i spread it too thinly, it will crack. But if I do 2 coats, it works much better!

i dont really like this eyeliner i love everything else at elf but this id so far the only thing i dont care fore i dont like the way it go'ss on and it dont last for me and it cracks .. i thought maybe the one i got was bad so i got another one and tried it and same thing i dont like the tip of the wound its hard i wish it was soft

I wish they offered more color choices. I would like to see forest green, plum, copper to name a few. I also agree the applicator needs to be tweaked some to leave a thinner line. I was glad to see that Target had a gift 3 pack with black, silver and gold in it- fun!

i love E.L.F products. great quality and so affordable. i think i own just about everything they offer. i have some ehat sensitive skin and this makeup has never caused me a problem. the eyeliner goes on so fluidly and evenly. i just love it and use it everyday.

I LOVE this eyeliner!!! I put it on in the morning and it will still look good at the end of the day, would recommend it to anyone!! im pretty picky about my eyeliners too and this is deffinatley one of the best!

Love it along w their eyeliner pen! i think its the best bang for the buck!

This product works wonders! The only thing that you have to make sure of is that you practice practice practice! This applies to all liquid eyeliners because if you make one move, it can mess up your whole eye. I use this product every day on my upper lash line, it gives such an intense look and I get many compliments on my eyes during school.

I have struggled to fine an eyeliner that will give me the smooth line for the look I wanted to enhance my eyes, this product works great for me and is easy to use, the price is really a great deal.

the felt tip one runs out REALLY fast only really works for one or 2 uses kinda not even worth the dolor

i actually really like this product. It glides on easy and stays on all day!