I was really unimpressed by this mascara. I am constantly on the lookout for a mascara that meets my needs (waterproof, lengthening, volumizing, dramatic look) The brush was too flexible and so long that I was not able to apply the mascara so that it wasn't gloppy or being poked in the eye by the brush, or getting the mascara everywhere but my lashes. It went on clumpy and once dry flaked off and got into my eyes and irritated them. I was not even close to achieving the look this product claimed to create. I love L'Oreal, but this was a dud.

Had high hopes for this mascara. I am a huge fan of the Voluminous Carbon Black. But it was just a disappointment,mainly of four big points. 1. The product is very dry, so it tends to clump very easy, specially the more coats you add; I once ended up with tarantula lashes, I was not happy. 2. I bought in purple, that is more of a dark lilac, and it never gave any color payoff. 3. The wand. For me the brush is huge, so I had to be extra careful not smudge the mascara on my lid or face; also the way the bristles are,with the dry formula, for me it was a formula for tarantula lashes. And the final reason that I don't like the wand is that it is a flexible wand, so applying the mascara is also a bit of a hassle;honestly who thought that a flexible wand, specially with a dry formula was a good idea!. 4. This mascara flakes soooo much, it only takes about 4 hour of wear when you start noticing purple flakes on your cheeks. Well at least people can see my mascara is purple. For me this became a dud, and I have been trying to use it for the mas 5 weeks, so I gave it a good chance,but it is a mascara that I won't buy again.

I had such high hopes for this product!!! I blame my penchant for adorable packaging (there's pandas on them there packages!!!) and it came in a HUGE tube. Huge tube = huge lashes, right? Wrong!!! I looked like a 5 year old caught playing makeup. It was on my lids, there were clumps galore. Doves cried. I don't know. Extremely disappointed and will not purchase again.

I like this mascara but it does get a bit clumpy at times. some days it goes on great, others it doesnt. I dont like how I never know if I will have clumps or not

I was but a huge fan of this mascara, there is way too much hype over this product, while it did give my lashes a lot of length, it was very very clumpy!

Great mascara for me. Nice black color, applied easily and didn't clump. Lasted well.

This mascara definitely made my eyelashes appear longer. Unfortunately, they didn't look thicker so the overall effect wasn't great. I got the best results using this as a second coat on top of another mascara. That looked great. It really is waterproof and stayed on all day without smearing or flaking off. The tips of my lashes tended to get clumpy.

Love this mascara! Just wish it didn't dry out so fast...

This is a pretty good mascara especially for the price. It volumes and darkens my lashes for a thicker. fuller. longer look. The only thing is if you do a few coats it can get a little clumpy but besides that I love this.

This product did work for me in waterproof. I loved the blackest black and kept my eyelash curled all day and night and separates lashes. It didn't flake, smudge or run when you cry.

I really love this formula, but I DON"T love the wand/brush! I don't like the flexible wand. I don't understand the point of it. The formula is definitely long lasting, doesn't flake off or smudge. This stuff doesn't budge! It doesn't completely come off with soap and water so I use my eye makeup remover to finish the job.

Love this mascara it gave my eye lashes volume and boldness. The only thing I didn't like about this was that it dries fast. Other than that great product.

I really enjoy this mascara right after I purchase it. But it tends to dry out way too fast, making it so you really only get about two weeks worth of god use.

Pro's - makes my lashes longer and thicker as claimed. Cons- has a wet and clumpy formula so you have to be careful when applying. I don't experience noticeable flaking with it. Overall.... I do like it.

I honestly bought this for the packaging, but it turns out it was worth the purchase! Although I'm unhappy with the excessive amount of product on the tip, I learned to work with it and not waste it. With only one coat you see noticeable length and volume. It gives you such beautiful dramatic lashes. I love this more than my high end mascaras. I will definitely repurchase!