SHESPEAKS Your Power to Influence

HPV Vaccine, the first vaccine against cancer

SS Member Image By drodriguez 03.19.07
HPV Vaccine, the first vaccine against cancer
Share Tweet
In 2006 the HPV (Human Papillomavirus) vaccine Gardasil was FDA approved for 9-26 year old girls and women in America. HPV is the most common STD in the US, it's known to cause cervical cancer in women and 3,700 deaths per year. The vaccine tested 'effective' against the particular HPV strains for genital warts and strains leading to cervical cancer. This is the first vaccine to prevent cancer.

So what's the debate? The immunization committee has recommended this vaccine for all 11 and 12 year old girls. It is the first female only vaccine, the first to target an STD and most importantly the first to protect against cancer. However, in some states the decision to mandate this vaccine has been unpopular, watch the video to learn more.

Do you think all states should mandate this vaccine? How young is too young? And do you believe girls will become promiscuous because of it?

Make a Comment

Comment  *
  • Flowergirrl By Flowergirrl

    I agree with the posters who stated they didn't feel it was correct for this to be a prerequisite of attending school.  However, that would make insurance coverage mandatory for the vaccine.  I can't call this a moral issue with statistics as high as one in four girls being sexually assaulted in their lifetimes.  With this disease being so common, and asymptomatic at times, there isn't any guarantee that a partner would even be able to disclose their infection status.  I want my daughter vaccinated as soon as it's covered by our insurance.  This is a female only vaccine as of now, but men carry this disease too and I am looking forward to the vaccine being approved of and used for men so that I don't have to worry about my son accidentally infecting a partner.

  • mrs_hambone By mrs_hambone

    I think that it should kind of be mandated... I'm in Texas where it already has been mandated.  I think when you take your daughter to the Dr. he/she should inform you of all the details of the vaccine and then allow you to opt out of having your daughter have the vaccine.  It should be address at each Dr's visit until the girl has been given the vaccine or she turns 18. 

    I don't see the harm in any vaccine that will protect your child's health.  But it should be an option that is desided on after all the information has been given.

    If it is mandated I don't think it's fair to have the price be awful either.  The drug company should be forced to offer it at a reasonable price.

  • mom2aroo By mom2aroo

    Even if my state *required* it to be given, I would not gve it to my daughter until I chose to do so, if even then. I think its a good new vax but its too new to be *required* and I myself havent gotten it & wont until its been around a little longer. If I knew my child was sexually active or even might be, I might but I think the age/requirments for this have been taken out of control.

  • mrs_hambone By mrs_hambone

    I did hear though that the vaccine is more effective the earlier the girl recives it.  If she's already sexually active than it's MUCH less effective, even if she hasn't contracted HPV yet.  So the age mandates make a lot of sence in that context, especially considering many girls are have sex at ages that are drastically younger than years ago. 

    That being said, I still don't think it should be a required vaccine for going to school.  I think a mandate is fine as long as parents have the option to op-out after being fully informed about the vaccine from a Dr.  Though that's putting a lot of pressure on Doctors to fully inform patients, and unfortunatly many do not do so.

  • TXMomma3 By TXMomma3

    I do not think anyone should make me vaccinate my child. There needs to be more testing done on this vaccine!

  • rebeccamarbas By rebeccamarbas

    Hi all,

    what a very serious question and so many different veiw points. I have been a nurse for over 17 years. Unfortunately there are many times when a woman or girls life can be sex and by violence. I think the thing to remember here is the prevention of cancer. I have a daughter and 2 son's. Morally my husband and I have taught abstinance. Realistically speaking it is doubtful that any of our children will make it to marriage a virgin or their partner one either. Rape whether it's date rape or whatever occurs in 1 in every 4 women. There are so many variables to think of if you wanted to make this about morality. To me it's much more straight forward. Choice is not always with our daughters...and having to tell a 12 year old and her mother that she now has AIDs because of a violent attack on her person...I had to stop and think when I read this blog. Is this vaccine really about sex?? or is it about giving our children as much protection as we can? Like I said for me it simple. Do I want my children having sex? No. Do I want my daughter to die from cancer when I can prevent that? Never

  • StaceyLynne By StaceyLynne

    Seems like more research is warranted and until then it should be optional.

  • mamaof2dvlkids By mamaof2dvlkids

    I wish the HPV vaccine had came around a little earlier. I had HPV that developed into cancer and had to have a hysterectomy. Since then i got remarried and my husband has not children of his own. My advice to all mothers and young women is to get the vaccine and never miss a pap.

  • lovelystar184 By lovelystar184

    This seems like it should be a good thing, but the fact that is still so new and since we have no idea what the long term side effects of this vaccine are there is no way that the government should make this mandatory.

  • crazed_mama07 By crazed_mama07

    I applaud the vaccine, but not the mass influx of direct-to-consumer marketing. People see this as a way to prevent cancer. It's not. I know a woman who was diagnosed with cervical cancer a few months back. Her fiance was devastated, as was she, but not for the same reason. She was dealing with a diagnosis of cancer at the age of 23. He was wondering how his fiance, the only person he'd ever been with, had contracted HPV. She did not have HPV. Because of the media hype for this vaccine, he believed that her cervical cancer was caused by HPV.

More stories like this