Go with Chicco!
I absolutely love this car seat. I actually purchased it, returned it because I needed a different stroller which came with a car seat, only to buy it again because the new car seat was nowhere near as nice as this one was; I love this seat so much I purchased an adapter so it could fit on my favorite stroller even though the stroller came with its own car seat. The material seems to be high quality. I feel the car seat is safe for my newborn son and I love the ease of snapping it in and out of the car. I have tried many different brands of car seats and this is my favorite one.